Leo Howell, ESPN Staff
Close Daily fantasy contributor
Mar 13, 2018, 08:22 PM It's amazing how one little change in settings can shift your perspective on a draft.
In our first mock draft of the season using rotisserie categories, which you can read about here , I had the final pick in the draft and spent it on my starting catcher. That's because, in an ESPN standard league with only one catcher required, I don't see the need to reach for catcher No. 2 when I can be virtually assured of getting catcher No. 10 at the end of the draft. There isn't enough of a difference between most of the options at the position, and they all carry extra risk due to the physical demands of the catcher role.
But when we loaded into the draft room for this most recent mock draft, using a two-catcher format, I took the second catcher of the draft with the 60th pick: Buster Posey . That's because the difference from Posey to replacement level in this league is much more stark, and it reinforces the need to secure a top option at the position. Not all of my peers agreed, and I was happy to take Brian McCann in the 20th round as the 12th catcher off the board, giving my team two potential top-10 players at a position many punted.
While it's true that I get no bonus points for having the best catchers, I know that I likely won't be stuck fishing for catchers on a waiver wire that would be led by names such as Tucker Barnhart , Chris Iannetta and Christian Vazquez , all rostered in fewer than 5 percent of ESPN leagues at this time. The catcher pool thins out quickly, so in a two-catcher league, you might need to dive in sooner than you think.
Find out who went where in this 10-team, head-to-head categories mock draft below.
The drafters for this mock: Leo Howell, Tristan H. Cockcroft, Ben Arledge, Kyle Soppe, Pierre Becquey, Eric Karabell, AJ Mass, Dan Mullen, Tony Moss, Damian Dabrowski.
Round 1 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Mike Trout , LAA, OF1 1 OF1 Howell Jose Altuve , HOU, 2B2 2 2B1 Cockcroft Nolan Arenado , COL, 3B3 3 3B1 Arledge Mookie Betts , BOS, OF4 4 OF2 Soppe Trea Turner , WSH, SS5 5 SS1 Becquey Charlie Blackmon , COL, OF6 6 OF3 Karabell Bryce Harper , WSH, OF7 7 OF4 Mass Paul Goldschmidt , ARI, 1B8 8 1B1 Mullen Carlos Correa , HOU, SS9 9 SS2 Moss Giancarlo Stanton , NYY, OF10 10 OF5 Dabrowski Round 2 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Kris Bryant , CHC, 3B1 11 3B2 Dabrowski Clayton Kershaw , LAD, SP2 12 SP1 Moss Max Scherzer , WSH, SP3 13 SP2 Mullen Corey Kluber , CLE, SP4 14 SP3 Mass Chris Sale , BOS, SP5 15 SP4 Karabell Joey Votto , CIN, 1B6 16 1B2 Becquey J.D. Martinez , BOS, OF7 17 OF6 Soppe Francisco Lindor , CLE, SS8 18 SS3 Arledge Manny Machado , BAL, 3B9 19 3B3 Cockcroft Freddie Freeman , ATL, 1B10 20 1B3 Howell Round 3 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Jose Ramirez , CLE, 2B1 21 2B2 Howell Anthony Rizzo , CHC, 1B2 22 1B4 Cockcroft Aaron Judge , NYY, OF3 23 OF7 Arledge Madison Bumgarner , SF, SP4 24 SP5 Soppe Josh Donaldson , TOR, 3B5 25 3B4 Becquey George Springer , HOU, OF6 26 OF8 Karabell Cody Bellinger , LAD, 1B7 27 1B5 Mass Corey Seager , LAD, SS8 28 SS4 Mullen Stephen Strasburg , WSH, SP9 29 SP6 Moss Brian Dozier , MIN, 2B10 30 2B3 Dabrowski Round 4 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Noah Syndergaard , NYM, SP1 31 SP7 Dabrowski Justin Upton , LAA, OF2 32 OF9 Moss Gary Sanchez , NYY, C3 33 C1 Mullen Christian Yelich , MIL, OF4 34 OF10 Mass Jose Abreu , CWS, 1B5 35 1B6 Karabell Kenley Jansen , LAD, RP6 36 RP1 Becquey Alex Bregman , HOU, SS7 37 SS5 Soppe Luis Severino , NYY, SP8 38 SP8 Arledge Carlos Carrasco , CLE, SP9 39 SP9 Cockcroft Zack Greinke , ARI, SP10 40 SP10 Howell Round 5 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Dee Gordon , SEA, 2B1 41 2B4 Howell Anthony Rendon , WSH, 3B2 42 3B5 Cockcroft Jacob deGrom , NYM, SP3 43 SP11 Arledge Andrew Benintendi , BOS, OF4 44 OF11 Soppe Nelson Cruz , SEA, DH5 45 DH1 Becquey Edwin Encarnacion , CLE, 1B6 46 1B7 Karabell Justin Verlander , HOU, SP7 47 SP12 Mass Marcell Ozuna , STL, OF8 48 OF12 Mullen Craig Kimbrel , BOS, RP9 49 RP2 Moss Rhys Hoskins , PHI, 1B10 50 1B8 Dabrowski Round 6 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Yu Darvish , CHC, SP1 51 SP13 Dabrowski Starling Marte , PIT, OF2 52 OF13 Moss Justin Turner , LAD, 3B3 53 3B6 Mullen Robbie Ray , ARI, SP4 54 SP14 Mass Chris Archer , TB, SP5 55 SP15 Karabell Wil Myers , SD, 1B6 56 1B9 Becquey Carlos Martinez , STL, SP7 57 SP16 Soppe Jonathan Schoop , BAL, 2B8 58 2B5 Arledge Khris Davis , OAK, OF9 59 OF14 Cockcroft Buster Posey , SF, C10 60 C2 Howell Round 7 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Yoenis Cespedes , NYM, OF1 61 OF15 Howell Byron Buxton , MIN, OF2 62 OF16 Cockcroft Aroldis Chapman , NYY, RP3 63 RP3 Arledge Robinson Cano , SEA, 2B4 64 2B6 Soppe A.J. Pollock , ARI, OF5 65 OF17 Becquey Elvis Andrus , TEX, SS6 66 SS6 Karabell Tommy Pham , STL, OF7 67 OF18 Mass James Paxton , SEA, SP8 68 SP17 Mullen Eric Hosmer , SD, 1B9 69 1B10 Moss Corey Knebel , MIL, RP10 70 RP4 Dabrowski Round 8 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Gerrit Cole , HOU, SP1 71 SP18 Dabrowski DJ LeMahieu , COL, 2B2 72 2B7 Moss Willson Contreras , CHC, C3 73 C3 Mullen Aaron Nola , PHI, SP4 74 SP19 Mass Miguel Sano , MIN, 3B5 75 3B7 Karabell Roberto Osuna , TOR, RP6 76 RP5 Becquey Jean Segura , SEA, SS7 77 SS7 Soppe Dallas Keuchel , HOU, SP8 78 SP20 Arledge Jose Quintana , CHC, SP9 79 SP21 Cockcroft Joey Gallo , TEX, 3B10 80 3B8 Howell Round 9 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Kyle Hendricks , CHC, SP1 81 SP22 Howell Xander Bogaerts , BOS, SS2 82 SS8 Cockcroft Ryan Braun , MIL, OF3 83 OF19 Arledge Masahiro Tanaka , NYY, SP4 84 SP23 Soppe Whit Merrifield , KC, 2B5 85 2B8 Becquey Daniel Murphy , WSH, 2B6 86 2B9 Karabell Rougned Odor , TEX, 2B7 87 2B10 Mass Shohei Ohtani, LAA, SP 8 88 SP24 Mullen Billy Hamilton , CIN, OF9 89 OF20 Moss Lorenzo Cain , MIL, OF10 90 OF21 Dabrowski Round 10 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Travis Shaw , MIL, 3B1 91 3B9 Dabrowski Andrew McCutchen , SF, OF2 92 OF22 Moss Yasiel Puig , LAD, OF3 93 OF23 Mullen Edwin Diaz , SEA, RP4 94 RP6 Mass Nicholas Castellanos , DET, 3B5 95 3B10 Karabell Trevor Story , COL, SS6 96 SS9 Becquey Ken Giles , HOU, RP7 97 RP7 Soppe Adam Jones , BAL, OF8 98 OF24 Arledge Domingo Santana , MIL, OF9 99 OF25 Cockcroft Raisel Iglesias , CIN, RP10 100 RP8 Howell Round 11 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Jake Arrieta , PHI, SP1 101 SP25 Howell Rich Hill , LAD, SP2 102 SP26 Cockcroft Jose Berrios , MIN, SP3 103 SP27 Arledge Luis Castillo , CIN, SP4 104 SP28 Soppe Ian Desmond , COL, 1B5 105 1B11 Becquey Manuel Margot , SD, OF6 106 OF26 Karabell Rafael Devers , BOS, 3B7 107 3B11 Mass Kyle Seager , SEA, 3B8 108 3B12 Mullen Mike Moustakas , KC, 3B9 109 3B13 Moss Cody Allen , CLE, RP10 110 RP9 Dabrowski Round 12 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Salvador Perez , KC, C1 111 C4 Dabrowski Carlos Santana , PHI, 1B2 112 1B12 Moss Lance McCullers Jr ., HOU, SP3 113 SP29 Mullen Luke Weaver , STL, SP4 114 SP30 Mass Jon Lester , CHC, SP5 115 SP31 Karabell Eddie Rosario , MIN, OF6 116 OF27 Becquey Adam Eaton , WSH, OF7 117 OF28 Soppe Adrian Beltre , TEX, 3B8 118 3B14 Arledge Felipe Rivero , PIT, RP9 119 RP10 Cockcroft Justin Smoak , TOR, 1B10 120 1B13 Howell Round 13 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Trevor Bauer , CLE, SP1 121 SP32 Howell Evan Gattis , HOU, C2 122 C5 Cockcroft Gregory Polanco , PIT, OF3 123 OF29 Arledge Alex Colome , TB, RP4 124 RP11 Soppe Sean Doolittle , WSH, RP5 125 RP12 Becquey Zack Godley , ARI, SP6 126 SP33 Karabell J.T. Realmuto , MIA, C7 127 C6 Mass Wade Davis , COL, RP8 128 RP13 Mullen Alex Wood , LAD, SP9 129 SP34 Moss Didi Gregorius , NYY, SS10 130 SS10 Dabrowski Round 14 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Chris Taylor , LAD, 2B1 131 2B11 Dabrowski Sonny Gray , NYY, SP2 132 SP35 Moss Javier Baez , CHC, SS3 133 SS11 Mullen Ozzie Albies , ATL, 2B4 134 2B12 Mass Brad Hand , SD, RP5 135 RP14 Karabell Wilson Ramos , TB, C6 136 C7 Becquey Jake Lamb , ARI, 3B7 137 3B15 Soppe Josh Bell , PIT, 1B8 138 1B14 Arledge Eduardo Nunez , BOS, 2B9 139 2B13 Cockcroft Nomar Mazara , TEX, OF10 140 OF30 Howell Round 15 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Paul DeJong , STL, SS1 141 SS12 Howell Matt Olson , OAK, 1B2 142 1B15 Cockcroft Adam Duvall , CIN, OF3 143 OF31 Arledge Miguel Cabrera , DET, 1B4 144 1B16 Soppe Welington Castillo , CWS, C5 145 C8 Becquey Yoan Moncada , CWS, 2B6 146 2B14 Karabell Kevin Kiermaier , TB, OF7 147 OF32 Mass Ender Inciarte , ATL, OF8 148 OF33 Mullen Matt Carpenter , STL, 1B9 149 1B17 Moss Jeff Samardzija , SF, SP10 150 SP36 Dabrowski Round 16 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Ian Happ , CHC, 2B1 151 2B15 Dabrowski Brett Gardner , NYY, OF2 152 OF34 Moss David Price , BOS, SP3 153 SP37 Mullen Jeurys Familia , NYM, RP4 154 RP15 Mass Greg Bird , NYY, 1B5 155 1B18 Karabell Hector Neris , PHI, RP6 156 RP16 Becquey Michael Conforto , NYM, OF7 157 OF35 Soppe Gio Gonzalez , WSH, SP8 158 SP38 Arledge Arodys Vizcaino , ATL, RP9 159 RP17 Cockcroft Mark Melancon , SF, RP10 160 RP18 Howell Round 17 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Blake Treinen , OAK, RP1 161 RP19 Howell Steven Souza Jr ., ARI, OF2 162 OF36 Cockcroft Jay Bruce , NYM, OF3 163 OF37 Arledge Mike Zunino , SEA, C4 164 C9 Soppe Max Kepler , MIN, OF5 165 OF38 Becquey Marcus Stroman , TOR, SP6 166 SP39 Karabell Tim Anderson , CWS, SS7 167 SS13 Mass Kyle Schwarber , CHC, OF8 168 OF39 Mullen Greg Holland , FA, RP9 169 RP20 Moss Trey Mancini , BAL, 1B10 170 1B19 Dabrowski Round 18 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Delino DeShields , TEX, OF1 171 OF40 Dabrowski Dylan Bundy , BAL, SP2 172 SP40 Moss Marwin Gonzalez , HOU, SS3 173 SS14 Mullen Garrett Richards , LAA, SP4 174 SP41 Mass Ronald Acuna, ATL, OF 5 175 OF41 Karabell Eric Thames , MIL, 1B6 176 1B20 Becquey Kevin Gausman , BAL, SP7 177 SP42 Soppe Jon Gray , COL, SP8 178 SP43 Arledge Johnny Cueto , SF, SP9 179 SP44 Cockcroft Michael Taylor , WSH, OF10 180 OF42 Howell Round 19 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Bradley Zimmer , CLE, OF1 181 OF43 Howell Yadier Molina , STL, C2 182 C10 Cockcroft Justin Bour , MIA, 1B3 183 1B21 Arledge Jose Martinez , STL, 1B4 184 1B22 Soppe Danny Duffy , KC, SP5 185 SP45 Becquey Archie Bradley , ARI, RP6 186 RP21 Karabell Todd Frazier , NYM, 3B7 187 3B16 Mass Michael Fulmer , DET, SP8 188 SP46 Mullen Orlando Arcia , MIL, SS9 189 SS15 Moss Brandon Morrow , CHC, RP10 190 RP22 Dabrowski Round 20 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Chase Anderson , MIL, SP1 191 SP47 Dabrowski Yasmani Grandal , LAD, C2 192 C11 Moss Kelvin Herrera , KC, RP3 193 RP23 Mullen Corey Dickerson , PIT, OF4 194 OF44 Mass Aaron Sanchez , TOR, SP5 195 SP48 Karabell Charlie Morton , HOU, SP6 196 SP49 Becquey Logan Morrison , MIN, 1B7 197 1B23 Soppe Ryan Zimmerman , WSH, 1B8 198 1B24 Arledge Dexter Fowler , STL, OF9 199 OF45 Cockcroft Brian McCann , HOU, C10 200 C12 Howell Round 21 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Ian Kinsler , LAA, 2B1 201 2B16 Howell Taijuan Walker , ARI, SP2 202 SP50 Cockcroft Danny Salazar , CLE, SP3 203 SP51 Arledge Evan Longoria , SF, 3B4 204 3B17 Soppe Jacob Faria, TB, SP 5 205 SP52 Becquey Jonathan Villar , MIL, 2B6 206 2B17 Karabell Yuli Gurriel , HOU, 1B7 207 1B25 Mass Odubel Herrera , PHI, OF8 208 OF46 Mullen Lance Lynn , MIN, SP9 209 SP53 Moss Kenta Maeda , LAD, SP10 210 SP54 Dabrowski Round 22 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Robinson Chirinos , TEX, C1 211 C13 Dabrowski Blake Parker , LAA, RP2 212 RP24 Moss Andrew Miller , CLE, RP3 213 RP25 Mullen Gleyber Torres, NYY, SS 4 214 SS16 Mass Austin Hedges , SD, C5 215 C14 Karabell Brad Brach , BAL, RP6 216 RP26 Becquey Austin Barnes , LAD, C7 217 C15 Soppe Jonathan Lucroy , OAK, C8 218 C16 Arledge Alex Cobb , FA, SP9 219 SP55 Cockcroft Blake Snell , TB, SP10 220 SP56 Howell Round 23 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Dellin Betances , NYY, RP1 221 RP27 Howell Jameson Taillon , PIT, SP2 222 SP57 Cockcroft Travis d'Arnaud , NYM, C3 223 C17 Arledge Shane Greene , DET, RP4 224 RP28 Soppe Dinelson Lamet , SD, SP5 225 SP58 Becquey Fernando Rodney , MIN, RP6 226 RP29 Karabell Russell Martin , TOR, C7 227 C18 Mass Chris Davis , BAL, 1B8 228 1B26 Mullen Matt Wieters , WSH, C9 229 C19 Moss Matt Chapman , OAK, 3B10 230 3B18 Dabrowski Round 24 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Scooter Gennett , CIN, 2B1 231 2B18 Dabrowski Josh Reddick , HOU, OF2 232 OF47 Moss Mitch Haniger , SEA, OF3 233 OF48 Mullen Cam Bedrosian , LAA, RP4 234 RP30 Mass Julio Teheran , ATL, SP5 235 SP59 Karabell Zach Britton , BAL, RP6 236 RP31 Becquey Alex Claudio , TEX, RP7 237 RP32 Soppe Brad Boxberger , ARI, RP8 238 RP33 Arledge Eugenio Suarez , CIN, 3B9 239 3B19 Cockcroft Ryan McMahon , COL, 1B10 240 1B27 Howell Round 25 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Dansby Swanson , ATL, SS1 241 SS17 Howell Tyler Chatwood , CHC, SP2 242 SP60 Cockcroft Joakim Soria , CWS, RP3 243 RP34 Arledge Michael Wacha , STL, SP4 244 SP61 Soppe Lucas Giolito , CWS, SP5 245 SP62 Becquey Jorge Alfaro , PHI, C6 246 C20 Karabell Luiz Gohara , ATL, SP7 247 SP63 Mass Drew Pomeranz , BOS, SP8 248 SP64 Mullen Mallex Smith , TB, OF9 249 OF49 Moss Andrelton Simmons , LAA, SS10 250 SS18 Dabrowski Round 26 Pick Ovr. Pos. Rank Drafter Mike Clevinger , CLE, SP11 251 SP65 Dabrowski Kendrys Morales , TOR, DH12 252 DH2 Moss Cole Hamels , TEX, SP13 251 SP65 Mullen Matt Duffy , TB, SS14 254 SS19 Mass Scott Kingery, PHI, 2B 15 255 2B19 Karabell Avisail Garcia , CWS, OF16 256 OF50 Becquey Luke Gregerson , STL, RP17 257 RP35 Soppe Amed Rosario , NYM, SS18 254 SS19 Arledge Eduardo Rodriguez , BOS, SP19 251 SP65 Cockcroft Stephen Piscotty , OAK, OF20 256 OF50 Howell